My Mom’s Key Lime Pie has a great backstory. Back in the 1980s, she and my dad went to dinner at an old Austin restaurant and, for dessert, ordered Key Lime Pie. As they ate, they both agreed it was the best Key Lime Pie they’d ever had.
So the next day, my mom called the restaurant and asked for the recipe. The restaurant declined to give it out, but said the recipe was once featured in a cooking magazine. With two toddlers in tow, my mom tracked down that magazine at the Austin Public Library and quickly scribbled down a shorthand version in the back of her Joy of Cooking cookbook.
The binding of her old cookbook fell apart, but I saved the back page and have been making my version of that Key Lime Pie for years. I can’t wait for you to try it. And while I don’t want to totally oversell it, multiple friends have said this pie is literally “the best pie they have ever had.” I know my mom agrees! Would love to hear what you think, too!
Looking for some other pie recipes? Check out our Coconut Cream Pie, Bourbon Pecan, Classic Pumpkin, Dutch Apple, or Peach & Blueberry. So many to choose from! Hope you enjoy!
2 Responses
Dad & Bec just made this pie. Decided to use the Graham Crackers (Digestives Biscuits down here) as the Base – too much effort to organize the pastry base. We had our own limes.
It was excellent. Adding the Sour Cream to the whipped cream topping was amazing. Took it from too sweet to a smooth cream topping.
Very impressed
Hi! Thanks for the note! So glad to hear that you enjoyed the pie and love the modification for a digestives crust. The sour cream and whipped cream topping is delicious with fresh fruit, too, if you’re needing a really quick dessert! The sour cream is so surprising with vanilla. Stay tuned for more new recipes soon. Hugs, Marie